How Does an Appeal Work in California?

The Courts of Appeal are California’s intermediate courts of review. People who are not satisfied with a Trial Court decision can appeal their case in an Appellate Court. When a party to a prior case “appeals,” that party is asking a higher-level court to change what the Trial Court decided.

The role of the Courts of Appeal is not to give new trials, but to review the Superior Court record (court files and transcripts) to decide if legal errors were made. To do this, the Court of Appeals may hear arguments from each side. Each side gets a chance to make a presentation and to answer the judges’ questions. The oral arguments are open to the public, but there are no juries or witnesses in an appeal. The Courts of Appeal cannot review death penalty cases.

In each Court of Appeal, a panel of three judges, called “justices,” decides appeals from Superior Courts. The Courts of Appeal can agree with the decision of the Trial Court, agree in part and disagree in part, or disagree and reverse the Trial judge’s decision. The Courts’ decisions are called opinions. The opinions are public and are posted on the Supreme Court’s website.


Serving Southern California counties, SmartLaw is the best way to find the right qualified legal resource. SmartLaw is certified by the State Bar of California and the American Bar Association. SmartLaw is a public service of the Los Angeles County Bar Association.

The materials and information available on this website are for informational purposes only. The materials and information available on this website are not for the purpose of providing legal advice and should not be relied upon or used in place of legal advice from an attorney. You should contact an attorney to receive advice with respect to any particular issue or problem you may have. For free assistance finding the right legal resource, contact SmartLaw by calling (866)SMARTLAW or by visiting us at SmartLaw.org.